← all episodes

Failure (DeepSeek V4.1 Flash): a candle and a spice mill sunk through the bowl

Failed in 18 tool calls: 7 looks (1 close and low), 10 placements, 0 height corrections of 10 mm or less, 0 removals to inspect.

The rules ask for three plates stacked with a cup on top, an open bowl holding a spice mill and a candle, and a second cup. DeepSeek stacks the plates and checks them, then puts the mill and the candle into the bowl at a height of 25 mm each. After that it looks only from 45° above or from a distance, which shows the tops of the mill and candle sitting in the bowl. It never looks at the bowl level or close, the view that would show their bottoms coming out underneath it.

the instruction DeepSeek was given
Arrange all 8 distinct catalog objects on the empty table labelled S. Objects may rest on other placed objects. All objects, including elevated ones, must project fully within S, have actual support, and avoid mesh intersections. Directions refer to the world E/N/Up compass, not an object’s own front or back.

Place 2: plate (asset_2) directly on S.

Stack 3: plate (asset_3) directly on 2: plate (asset_2), with at least 80% of its projected footprint over that object.

Stack 1: plate (asset_1) directly on 3: plate (asset_3), with at least 80% of its projected footprint over that object.

Stack 5: drinking vessel (asset_5) directly on 1: plate (asset_1), with at least 80% of its projected footprint over that object.

Place 6: open bowl (asset_6) directly on S.

Put 4: spice mill (asset_4) inside 6: open bowl (asset_6), resting on its interior floor; its top may protrude above the rim.

Place 8: drinking vessel (asset_8) directly on S.

Put 7: candle (asset_7) inside 6: open bowl (asset_6), resting on its interior floor; its top may protrude above the rim.

The footprint of 8: drinking vessel (asset_8) must be world east of 2: plate (asset_2), with a shortest horizontal edge-to-edge gap of 4–25 cm and at least 5 cm of footprint-centroid displacement in that direction.

The footprint of 6: open bowl (asset_6) must be world east of 8: drinking vessel (asset_8), with a shortest horizontal edge-to-edge gap of 4–25 cm and at least 5 cm of footprint-centroid displacement in that direction.

Leave the entire world-north 6 cm edge strip of S empty, including projections of stacked objects. Inside means the entire projected footprint fits within the actual inner opening and the base rests below the rim; tops may protrude. Keep contents separate from one another and the walls. Any arrangement satisfying the rules is valid; there are no target coordinates. Choose every height explicitly; height=0 is S’s top. Use the calibrated catalog and adjustable camera views.

Why it failed

The spice mill (4) and the candle (7) were set too low for this bowl (6). Their bases end up 28 mm and 22 mm below the bowl's interior floor, so both pass through the bottom of the bowl. From the side the grey base of the candle shows underneath the bowl, next to its foot. After placing them (steps 12 and 13) DeepSeek took three close views at 45° and one wide view at 20° of the whole table (steps 14 to 17), then finished. None of them looks at the bowl from the side.

The finished scene, seen from views aimed at the problem
level (5°) view of the bowl from the south: the candle's grey base pokes out below the bowl, beside its foot
level (5°) view of the bowl from the south: the candle's grey base pokes out below the bowl, beside its foot
close view at 20° from the west: the candle inside the bowl, and its base showing underneath
close view at 20° from the west: the candle inside the bowl, and its base showing underneath
level (5°) view from the east
level (5°) view from the east

These views were rendered after the run: the model's own place and remove calls were replayed in the same environment (the rebuilt scene's overview image is pixel-identical to the last one the model saw), then the camera was aimed at the failure. The model never saw these views.

What the scorer measured
The catalog
catalog
image 3, the catalog: orthographic front, side and top views of each object with metric scale bars. Sent once; it never changes.
Every step at a glance (click to jump)
123456789101112131415161718
n close, low look at a contactn other viewn placen height correction of 10 mm or lessn remove to inspectn finish

Each box is one tool call. Left: the two current images DeepSeek had just been given (image 1, a fixed overview; image 2, the view it chose last). Right: what the call did and what came back. DeepSeek returns no readable reasoning in these runs, so the notes describe the actions. Images are the JPEGs exactly as sent. Click one for full size. Removals are marked with a coloured edge.

Step 1: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 1)
observation 1, image 1
image 1, fixed overview
observation 1, image 2
image 2, chosen view
Places asset_2 at height 0 mm above the table (on the table).
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_2", "east": -0.32, "north": 0, "height": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 2: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 2)
observation 2, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 2, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_3 at height 18 mm above the table, a height it has to work out itself from the catalog's scale bars and the views; nothing snaps into place.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_3", "east": -0.32, "height": 0.018, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 3: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 3)
observation 3, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 3, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Close, low look at asset_3: a close zoom aims at the object's base, where it meets what is under it, so it can see whether it floats or sinks in.
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 45, "elevation": 5, "zoom": "close", "focus": "asset_3"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 4: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 4)
observation 4, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 3
observation 4, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_3 again (placement 2), at 30 mm, +12 mm from its last placement.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_3", "east": -0.32, "height": 0.03, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 5: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 5)
observation 5, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 5, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_3 again (placement 3), at 15 mm, -15 mm from its last placement.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_3", "east": -0.32, "height": 0.015, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 6: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 6)
observation 6, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 6, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_1 at height 28 mm above the table, a height it has to work out itself from the catalog's scale bars and the views; nothing snaps into place.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_1", "east": -0.32, "height": 0.028, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 7: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 7)
observation 7, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 7, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_5 at height 40 mm above the table, a height it has to work out itself from the catalog's scale bars and the views; nothing snaps into place.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_5", "east": -0.32, "height": 0.04, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 8: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 8)
observation 8, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 8, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Looks: close view of asset_3 from the north, nearly overhead (75°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 0, "elevation": 75, "focus": "asset_3", "zoom": "close"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 9: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 9)
observation 9, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 8
observation 9, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_8 at height 0 mm above the table (on the table).
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_8", "east": -0.04, "height": 0, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 10: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 10)
observation 10, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 10, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_6 at height 0 mm above the table (on the table).
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_6", "east": 0.24, "height": 0, "north": 0, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 11: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 11)
observation 11, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 11, image 2
image 2, chosen view unchanged since observation 10
Looks: close view of asset_6 from the north, nearly overhead (75°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 0, "elevation": 75, "focus": "asset_6", "zoom": "close"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 12: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 12)
observation 12, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 11
observation 12, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_7 at height 25 mm above the table, a height it has to work out itself from the catalog's scale bars and the views; nothing snaps into place.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_7", "east": 0.205, "height": 0.025, "north": 0.01, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 13: place_object

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 13)
observation 13, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 13, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Places asset_4 at height 25 mm above the table, a height it has to work out itself from the catalog's scale bars and the views; nothing snaps into place.
Tool call
place_object {"asset_id": "asset_4", "east": 0.305, "height": 0.025, "north": -0.01, "yaw": 0}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 14: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 14)
observation 14, image 1
image 1, fixed overview new
observation 14, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Looks: close view of asset_6 from the north, angled (45°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 0, "elevation": 45, "focus": "asset_6", "zoom": "close"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 15: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 15)
observation 15, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 14
observation 15, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Looks: close view of asset_5 from the 60, angled (45°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 60, "elevation": 45, "focus": "asset_5", "zoom": "close"}
What came back
{"success": false, "error": "bearing must be one of [0, 45, 90, 135, 180, 225, 270, 315]", "error_type": "ValueError"}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 16: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 16)
observation 16, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 14
observation 16, image 2
image 2, chosen view unchanged since observation 15
Looks: close view of asset_5 from the north-east, angled (45°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 45, "elevation": 45, "focus": "asset_5", "zoom": "close"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 17: observe_scene

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 17)
observation 17, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 14
observation 17, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Looks: wide view of S (the table) from the north-west, low (20°).
Tool call
observe_scene {"bearing": 315, "elevation": 20, "focus": "S", "zoom": "wide"}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)

Step 18: finish

What DeepSeek was looking at when it chose this (observation 18)
observation 18, image 1
image 1, fixed overview unchanged since observation 14
observation 18, image 2
image 2, chosen view new
Finishes: it judges every rule satisfied.
Tool call
finish {}
What came back
{"success": true}
input 0 tokens (0 from cache), output 0 (0 of it hidden reasoning)